Help: Which lens would you keep?

[chibae]

I have two older, pre-autofocus, film era lenses. Both are 200mm 3.5. Both give fugly round out of focus circles in highlights. One has slightly more controllable purple fringing, but not by much. here they both are, the best shots from both. All focus issues were user error. Help me choose, I'm not selling both until I have a more modern equivalent, but I will sell/trade one of them.

Vivitar

Tamron Adaptall2

 

[tommyr]

I'd keep the Vivitar. Based on these 2 photos.

 

[Plant Planter]

I'd keep the Vivitar. Based on these 2 photos.

I agree.

 

[chibae]

I third..after future tests